Jules, Omer and Chris Discuss the Challenges of Big Data and Consumer Review Boards

Jules, Omer and Chris Discuss the Challenges of Big Data and Consumer Review Boards

FPF’s Co-Chair and Executive Director Jules Polonetsky, Senior Fellow Omer Tene, and Co-Chair Christopher Wolf discussed the challenges facing President Obama with respect to big data in a new post for the IAPP.  The post argues that balancing the benefits of data analytics against attendant risks to civil liberties presents the biggest public policy challenge of our time.

FPF is currently developing a toolkit designed to help privacy professionals perform a comprehensive, rigorous cost-benefit analysis to determine how best to pursue their big data goals. Companies should have a clear framework to use in order to evaluate how a data-driven project will affect their consumers. Recent articles about “people analytics” to guide hiring practices to a school’s tracking of its students add additional examples that make it clear that a “practical application of fair information principles that accounts for modern day realities of collection and use” has become increasingly necessary.

One potential path forward involves the creation of “Consumer Subject Review Boards,” an idea discussed by Ryan Calo.* Such review boards would assess and evaluate big data projects’ rewards and associated risks. They would play an instrumental role in revitalizing consumer trust and mitigating some of the risks associated with innovative uses of consumer data. However, there are still questions that must be answered before such review boards could be deployed in practice.

First, what type of issues would a review board address? Would it be focused on addressing only privacy dilemmas, or would it seek to anticipate other ethical issues? As Evan Selinger and Patrick Lin write: “A technology ethics board . . . can be an invaluable canary in the coalmine—scouting for explosive issues in advance of emerging technology and before the law eventually turns its attention to these new problems and the company itself.” Clearly, a review board would need to have a clear understanding of its proper subject-matter scope.

Another question is whether the review boards should be in-house or independent. An in-house review board would benefit from close familiarity with its company’s data practices, but would lack the credibility of an independent entity. Similarly, should the opinions of a review board be confidential or publicly available? Confidential opinions do not instill as much consumer trust; however, public opinions risk being watered down to mitigate future litigation risks, and could potentially chill valuable innovation.  Some companies have privacy advisory boards already – is a Consumer Review Board a more formal example of a privacy board?  What methodology will the members use?

We look forward to continuing to explore this promising idea.

 



* See also Malcolm Crompton’s suggestion of ethics boards for privacy issues.

Leave a Reply


Privacy Calendar

Nov
20
Thu
all-day W3C Workshop on Privacy and User... @ Berlin, Germany
W3C Workshop on Privacy and User... @ Berlin, Germany
Nov 20 – Nov 21 all-day
The Workshop on User Centric App Controls intents to further the discussion among stakeholders of the mobile web platform, including researchers, developers and service providers. This workshop serves to investigate strategies toward better privacy protection[...]
Dec
2
Tue
all-day IAPP Practical Privacy Series 2014
IAPP Practical Privacy Series 2014
Dec 2 – Dec 3 all-day
Government and FTC and Consumer Privacy return to Washington, DC. For more information, click here.
Dec
11
Thu
9:00 am Progress of the EU Data Protecti...
Progress of the EU Data Protecti...
Dec 11 @ 9:00 am
The EU Member States have agreed to conclude the negotiations on the EU Data Protection draft Regulation in 2015. The process will have arrived at a critical point by the end of this year. The[...]
Jan
26
Mon
8:30 am Privacy as a Profit Center: Leve... @ Old Slip by Convene
Privacy as a Profit Center: Leve... @ Old Slip by Convene
Jan 26 @ 8:30 am – Jan 27 @ 4:15 pm
Learn how those on the leading edge of privacy governance and digital innovation from companies including Cigna, Cisco Systems, eBay Inc. Public Policy Lab, FocusMotion,Ghostery, Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Google, HP Enterprise Security Products, JPMorgan[...]
Jan
28
Wed
all-day Data Privacy Day
Data Privacy Day
Jan 28 – Jan 29 all-day
“Data Privacy Day began in the United States and Canada in January 2008, as an extension of the Data Protection Day celebration in Europe. The Day commemorates the 1981 signing of Convention 108, the first[...]
Mar
4
Wed
all-day Global Privacy Summit 2015
Global Privacy Summit 2015
Mar 4 – Mar 6 all-day
For more information, click here.
Mar
10
Tue
6:00 pm CDT Annual Dinner “TechProm” 2015
CDT Annual Dinner “TechProm” 2015
Mar 10 @ 6:00 pm – 9:00 pm
Featuring the most influential minds of the tech policy world, CDT’s annual dinner, TechProm, highlights the issues your organization will be facing in the future and provides the networking opportunities that can help you tackle[...]

View Calendar