Safe Harbor: Time for a Fresh Look?

Safe Harbor: Time for a Fresh Look?

The fallout from the NSA revelations continue to make the national headlines.  But the impact isn’t simply limited to the government’s use of data.  Last week, the Chairman of the Article 29 Working Party wrote to the Vice-President of the European Commission to express “great concern” about PRISM and related intelligence programs, including how these programs impact companies’ compliance with the U.S.-E.U. Safe Harbor Program.  While the Safe Harbor does have a carve out for national security, the Article 29 Working Party “has doubts whether the seemingly large-scale and structural surveillance of personal data that has now emerged can still be considered an exception strictly limited to the extent necessary.”  The letter goes on to remind Member States that they have authority to suspend data flows where there is substantial likelihood that the Safe Harbor principles are being violated.

This is only the latest in a growing group of voices in the E.U. to question whether the Safe Harbor is working.  Germany’s data protection commissioner, for example, blogged that the United States data protection framework is lacking and that Safe Harbor “cannot compensate for these deficits.”   And just last month, Vivian Reding, Vice-President of the European Commission, called the Safe Harbor “a loophole” that “may not be so safe after all,” and has requested a full review of the program by year-end.

The Safe Harbor has been criticized in the past.  For example, one 2008 report found that a number of companies were falsely claiming to be in the Safe Harbor when they in fact had allowed their certifications to lapse.  However, in the years since it was last seriously assessed, there have been a number of positive developments.  The FTC has stepped up its enforcement efforts and settled a number of cases for Safe Harbor violations.  And, the number of companies to sign up to the Safe Harbor has grown.

We think that, in light of these concerns, it may be time to take an objective look at the Safe Harbor program.  As the European Commission undertakes its review, we should examine the current protections the Safe Harbor offers, as well as the compliance and enforcement efforts undertaken by both the E.U. and the U.S.  Let’s see what is working, and what isn’t.  And, if there are ways to make the Safe Harbor better, we should step up to the plate and offer solutions.

Leave a Reply


Privacy Calendar

Jan
26
Mon
8:30 am Privacy as a Profit Center: Leve... @ Old Slip by Convene
Privacy as a Profit Center: Leve... @ Old Slip by Convene
Jan 26 @ 8:30 am – Jan 27 @ 4:15 pm
Learn how those on the leading edge of privacy governance and digital innovation from companies including Cigna, Cisco Systems, eBay Inc. Public Policy Lab, FocusMotion,Ghostery, Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Google, HP Enterprise Security Products, JPMorgan[...]
Jan
28
Wed
all-day Data Privacy Day
Data Privacy Day
Jan 28 – Jan 29 all-day
“Data Privacy Day began in the United States and Canada in January 2008, as an extension of the Data Protection Day celebration in Europe. The Day commemorates the 1981 signing of Convention 108, the first[...]
Mar
4
Wed
all-day Global Privacy Summit 2015
Global Privacy Summit 2015
Mar 4 – Mar 6 all-day
For more information, click here.
Mar
10
Tue
6:00 pm CDT Annual Dinner “TechProm” 2015
CDT Annual Dinner “TechProm” 2015
Mar 10 @ 6:00 pm – 9:00 pm
Featuring the most influential minds of the tech policy world, CDT’s annual dinner, TechProm, highlights the issues your organization will be facing in the future and provides the networking opportunities that can help you tackle[...]
Mar
13
Fri
all-day BCLT Privacy Law Forum
BCLT Privacy Law Forum
Mar 13 all-day
This program will feature leading academics and practitioners discussing the latest developments in privacy law. UC Berkeley Law faculty and conference panelists will discuss cutting-edge scholarship and explore ‘real world’ privacy law problems. Click here[...]
May
27
Wed
all-day PL&B’s Asia-Pacific Roundtable (...
PL&B’s Asia-Pacific Roundtable (...
May 27 all-day
PROFESSOR GRAHAM GREENLEAF, Asia-Pacific Editor, Privacy Laws & Business International Report, will lead a roundtable on the countries of most interest to business in the Asia-Pacific region. Click here for more information.
Jul
6
Mon
all-day PL&B’s 28th Annual International...
PL&B’s 28th Annual International...
Jul 6 – Jul 8 all-day
The Privacy Laws & Business 27th Annual International Conference featured more than 40 speakers and chairs from many countries over 3 intensive days. At the world’s longest running independent international privacy event participants gained professionally by[...]

View Calendar