UK Parliament Rejects Commission’s Data Protection Proposal Despite Promise for More Flexibility

UK Parliament Rejects Commission’s Data Protection Proposal Despite Promise for More Flexibility

The European Commission’s Data Protection Reform Proposal came under fire in a just-issued report by the UK House of Commons Justice Committee that called the proposed Regulation “overly prescriptive” and lacking “flexibility or discretion” for data controllers and regulators. While The UK Justice Committee report concludes that a Regulation is necessary in order to update the 1995 Directive, and to account for the rapidly changing technological environment and address individuals’ rights, it does not believe that the current proposal is “proportionate, practicable, affordable or am effective system of data protection in the EU.”

EU Justice Commissioner Viviane Reding recently responded to similar criticism from Member States by outlining three key areas where flexibility could be added to the Commission’s existing draft data protection reform. Commissioner Reding’s announcement came during the Justice Council Meeting on October 26, 2012 in Luxemburg, several days before the EU Justice Committee released its report.

First, the Commissioner highlighted the reform’s intention to further reduce administrative burdens on companies and asserted the potential to broaden SME exemptions by taking an approach that accounts for the amount and sensitivity of the data processed.

Second, the Commissioner conceded that the delegated and implementing acts foreseen by the Regulation should be reviewed “one by one” and limited to cases in which they are “truly necessary.” However, Citing that Delegated and implementing acts are necessary in certain circumstances, Commissioner Reding  proposed three specific review criteria that should determine each case. The Commissioner believes these criteria could lead to a reduction of Commission empowerment by 40%: (1) “need to avoid fragmentation”, (2) “the need to supplement rather than amend the regulation”, and (3) “maintaining the technologically neutral character of law.”

Third, the Commissioner acknowledged that specific rules for public sector data processing are necessary in some cases; and that the Commission is willing to introduce more legislative flexibility on this point. However, Commissioner Reding believes that this necessary flexibility can and should be achieved through regulation and asserts that the Commission’s draft “already foresees 20 cases in which specific rules are adapted to the public sector.”

It is unclear how the UK Justice Committee’s report, which largely calls for the Draft Data Protection Reform to be re-written, will affect current discussions in the EU Parliament and Council.

-Julian Flamant

Leave a Reply


Privacy Calendar

Oct
21
Tue
6:00 pm Consumer Action’s 43rd Annual Aw... @ Google
Consumer Action’s 43rd Annual Aw... @ Google
Oct 21 @ 6:00 pm – Oct 21 @ 8:00 pm
To mark its 43rd anniversary, Consumer Action’s Annual Awards Reception on October 21, 2014, will celebrate the theme of “Train the Trainer.” Through the power of individual and small group trainings, Consumer Action each year is[...]
Oct
24
Fri
9:00 am Web Privacy & Transparency Confe... @ Princeton University
Web Privacy & Transparency Confe... @ Princeton University
Oct 24 @ 9:00 am – 4:00 pm
On Friday, October 24, 2014, the Center for Information Technology Policy (CITP) at Princeton University is hosting a public conference on Web Privacy and Transparency. It will explore the quickly emerging area of computer science research that[...]
Oct
29
Wed
4:00 pm Big Data and Privacy: Navigating... @ Schulze Hall
Big Data and Privacy: Navigating... @ Schulze Hall
Oct 29 @ 4:00 pm – 7:00 pm
The rapid emergence of “big data” has created many benefits and risks for businesses today. As data is collected, stored, analyzed, and deployed for various business purposes, it is particularly important to develop responsible data[...]
Oct
30
Thu
9:00 am The Privacy Act @40: A Celebrati... @ Georgetown Law
The Privacy Act @40: A Celebrati... @ Georgetown Law
Oct 30 @ 9:00 am – 5:30 pm
The Privacy Act @40 A Celebration and Appraisal on the 40th Anniversary of the Privacy Act and the 1974 Amendments to the Freedom of Information Act October 30, 2014 Agenda 9 – 9:15 a.m. Welcome[...]
Nov
7
Fri
all-day George Washington Law Review 201... @ George Washington University Law School
George Washington Law Review 201... @ George Washington University Law School
Nov 7 – Nov 8 all-day
Save the date for the GW Law Review‘s Annual Symposium, The FTC at 100: Centennial Commemorations and Proposals for Progress, which will be held on Saturday, November 8, 2014, in Washington, DC. This year’s symposium, hosted in[...]
Nov
11
Tue
10:15 am You Are Here: GPS Location Track... @ Mauna Lani Bay Hotel & Bungalows
You Are Here: GPS Location Track... @ Mauna Lani Bay Hotel & Bungalows
Nov 11 @ 10:15 am
EFF Staff Attorney Hanni Fakhoury will present twice at the Oregon Criminal Defense Lawyers Association’s Annual Sunny Climate Seminar. He will give a presentation on government location tracking issues and then participate in a panel[...]
Dec
2
Tue
all-day IAPP Practical Privacy Series 2014
IAPP Practical Privacy Series 2014
Dec 2 – Dec 3 all-day
Government and FTC and Consumer Privacy return to Washington, DC. For more information, click here.

View Calendar