Missing the Consumer Value of Social Media

Missing the Consumer Value of Social Media

I love Consumer Reports.   I rely on the magazine for top notch reviews.  Their testing of consumer products is unbiased and invaluable to anyone who takes both price and value seriously. I am currently looking to purchase a quality home treadmill and was pleased to see that a recent issue included a detailed report based on hands on testing and detailed consumer surveys.  But before I make a final decision, I will reach out to my Facebook social network friends for their input.  Some of them will have personal experience researching this type of purchase, others will know me and my foibles and perhaps advise that I get one that works with the new fitness apps available or a longer track so I don’t fall off while multi-tasking.

Facebook and other social media tools have empowered consumers more than any other development in many years, except perhaps for the creation of Consumer Reports itself.  Consumers have a megaphone to voice and spread their concerns about any business or product in a way that demands a reaction.  Companies dedicate special teams to follow opinions about their brands on social media and employ specialists to respond to individual concerns.

Certainly social media has its downsides.  Despite improvements in recent years, privacy controls are still not intuitive.  For years, posting online was public while email and chat were private.  Now, depending on our settings and which service we are using, our posts may be public, our pictures may be private and our location check-ins may be available to “friends of friends”.  It can get very complicated.

What’s the point of sharing with a friend of a friend? The other day I was complaining on Facebook about a new airplane baggage fee when a friend responded to commiserate.  But then she tagged her friend the travel agent who jumped in with great expert advice about how to avoid that fee.  Privacy concerns about sharing my travel plans?  In my neighborhood, folks on my block and friends of my kids know when we are on vacation.  If I forget to stop the newspaper delivery, they pick it up for me.  Don’t announce it to the general public, where some crook may scour public information for evil purposes.  But online or offline, sharing with your friends or community does far more to empower most of us than it does to create any new risks.

I was surprised therefor to see the harshly negative general view Consumer Reports took towards Facebook in the issue released yesterday.  I expected criticism of the usability of privacy controls or complaints about apps that ask consumers for more information than they need.  Facebook is aware of those issues and is working with our think tank and others on the best ways to continue to make progress ensuring that the thousands of developers who create their own consumer apps use data responsibly.  But Consumer Reports seems to be taking the view that social media sharing is by definition a bad idea, even when people are sharing with their own friends.  True, things posted privately can be further shared, but that’s the case with much of what we do online and the price for convenience we make every day when we use email to send information around the world.

Consumer Reports notes with alarm that millions of people are publicly showing support for the battles against various illnesses by publicly “liking” pages dedicated to the diseases.  I would like to urge more consumers to “like” the fights to cure and de-stigmatize disease.  And I think it is preposterous to think that if I announce that I am attending a march to raise money to fund breast cancer research that an insurer will be able to use it against me.  Are there any companies that are mistreating people for such activity? I would like Consumer Reports to find out, so I can denounce them on Facebook for my friends to read and pass on and on.

It was also surprising to see media reports alarmed at Consumer Reports finding that 13 million people were unfamiliar with Facebook privacy controls.  With 188 million users in Facebook and Canada (the regions surveyed) this means that more than 90% of users say they are familiar with the controls.  That is remarkably positive!

Certainly folks who post compromising pictures or comments, on Facebook or on blogs or anywhere public, should understand that friends, employers, colleges, prospective dates will judge you.  Do a search using Google and see what shows up.  You have a digital identity that is being used to assess you, just like the clothes you wear every day and the people you associate with form your public identity.  As more is available online, Facebook, Google and others needs to help us shape that identity to put our best self forward to those who are interested in us.  Which online services are doing the most to help consumers pro-actively shape their reputations and empower them to make smarter decisions?  That’s the Consumer Reports study that I would like to see.  But by applying a pessimistic eye towards social media in general as it conducted this survey, this month’s Consumer Reports magazine isn’t going to be a “best value” for today’s online consumer.

 

-Jules Polonetsky

Leave a Reply


Privacy Calendar

Sep
15
Mon
all-day NIST Privacy Engineering Workshop @ San Jose Marriott
NIST Privacy Engineering Workshop @ San Jose Marriott
Sep 15 – Sep 16 all-day
Privacy is a challenging subject that spans a number of domains, including law, policy and technology. Notwithstanding numerous sets of principles, including the foundational Fair Information Practice Principles (FIPPs), that seek to address the handling[...]
Sep
17
Wed
all-day IAPP Privacy Academy and CSA Con... @ San Jose Convention Center
IAPP Privacy Academy and CSA Con... @ San Jose Convention Center
Sep 17 – Sep 19 all-day
This fall, the International Association of Privacy Professionals (IAPP) and Cloud Security Alliance (CSA) are bringing together the IAPP Privacy Academy and the CSA Congress under one roof, giving you access to even more valuable[...]
Sep
19
Fri
The NSA, Privacy and the Global ... @ Georgetown Law Center
The NSA, Privacy and the Global ... @ Georgetown Law Center
Sep 19 @ 1:15 pm – 2:45 pm
WHAT The NSA, Privacy and the Global Internet: Perspectives on Executive Order 12333 WHEN Friday, September 19, 2014 1:15 – 2:45 p.m. WHERE Georgetown University Law Center McDonough Hall, Room 200 600 New Jersey Avenue,[...]
Sep
23
Tue
Mapping Issues with the Web: An ... @ Tow Center for Digital Journalism/Columbia Journalism School
Mapping Issues with the Web: An ... @ Tow Center for Digital Journalism/Columbia Journalism School
Sep 23 @ 5:00 pm – 6:30 pm
On the occasion of Bruno Latour’s visit to Columbia University, this presentation will show participants how to operationalize his seminal Actor-Network Theory using digital data and methods in the service of social and cultural research.
Sep
26
Fri
Yale Day of Data @ Yale University
Yale Day of Data @ Yale University
Sep 26 @ 8:30 am – 5:00 pm
This day-long event will focus on data science and partnerships across industry, academia, and government initiatives. The day will also include presentations by eight Yale faculty and researchers on issues specific to research data management,[...]
Oct
11
Sat
City by Numbers: Big Data and th... @ Pratt Institute
City by Numbers: Big Data and th... @ Pratt Institute
Oct 11 @ 9:30 am – 6:00 pm
Big Data—the exponential growth and availability of information—is one of the defining phenomena of our time. It affects us all on different levels – with far-reaching social, environmental, and governmental significance. To help make sense[...]
Oct
21
Tue
Consumer Action’s 43rd Annual Aw... @ Google
Consumer Action’s 43rd Annual Aw... @ Google
Oct 21 @ 6:00 pm – Oct 21 @ 8:00 pm
To mark its 43rd anniversary, Consumer Action’s Annual Awards Reception on October 21, 2014, will celebrate the theme of “Train the Trainer.” Through the power of individual and small group trainings, Consumer Action each year is[...]

View Calendar