Tracking Progress on Do Not Track

Tracking Progress on Do Not Track

The Tracking Protection Working Group of the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) met last week in Washington, D.C. to further its efforts in developing industry standards for Do Not Track (DNT) measures. As deadlines for public release of the specifications near, the pressure is on for the group to come to agreement on critical policy questions around Do Not Track. The group has made a lot of progress on some issues such as reaching general agreement that DNT is primarily aimed at third parties who collect data at sites. However, substantial debate continues around the definition of a third party and what those third parties can do with data when the DNT header is “on.”

Some stakeholder participants maintain that DNT should give consumers the ability to block most data collection by third parties, and only allow collection and retention for limited specified purposes, such as fraud and security. Other participants maintain that they need to be able to collect more data under DNT in order to perform business functions such as frequency capping, auditing, financial logging, and market research.

FTC Commissioner Julie Brill made a guest appearance to show the FTC’s support for the W3C’s efforts, identifying it as one of three major DNT processes underway-the other accompanying processes are the advertising trade groups’ self-regulatory program and popular browsers that have implemented do not track mechanisms. The FTC set the stage for a future DNT framework in its Final Privacy Report released last month. The report called for a Do Not Track standard to mean more than just “Do Not Target” and to have elements of “Do Not Collect.” Failing the inclusion of this, the FTC indicated it would support DNT legislation. However, Commissioner Brill stated that she, along with FTC Chairman Jon Leibowitz, is confident that there will be an effective DNT framework by the end of the year.

Why is tracking so important for companies, if they have already agreed to allow users to opt-out of behavioral advertising? Tiny banner ads are a poor way to influence users compared to the richness of TV, radio, and magazines. But banner ads and their effectiveness can be precisely measured in ways that the other media cannot be (yet!). Advertisers still spend the bulk of their dollars offline, even though users increasingly spend large chunks of their day on the web. The big value add for many web publishers is their ability to report which ads on which sites were successful in causing users to transact on other sites and later in time.

For some, allowing the logging of data needed for such cross-site tracking creates too many risks. They worry the government might seek the data or they do not trust companies to refrain from using it for profiling or for discriminatory purposes. Others argue that consumers who are promised that they will not be tracked expect not to be tracked at all.

We believe that the potential compromise solution will need to allow for the basics of analytics and ad reporting, while relying on de-identification and retention limits as well as contractual and policy commitments to minimize privacy risks.

We were surprised to see Yahoo called out yesterday by the WSJ as “leading the charge” against DNT. If a DNT compromise is reached, no individual on the industry side will be more deserving of credit than Yahoo’s Shane Wiley. He and his team at Yahoo have spent countless hours on proposals seeking to bridge the differences among companies and other stakeholders. The volume of emails in our inbox and on the W3C listserv is a testament to that.

There is still much work to be done and the next weeks will be critical.

For a detailed analysis of the Do Not Track debate, read Jules Polonetsky and Omer Tene’s paper, “To Track or Do Not Track.”

 

-Lia Sheena

Leave a Reply


Privacy Calendar

Apr
24
Thu
all-day 6th Biannual International Surveillance & Society Conference
6th Biannual International Surve…
Apr 24 – Apr 25 all-day
The 6th Biannual International Surveillance & Society conference hosted by the University of Barcelona and supported by the Surveillance Studies Network is currently calling for [...]
Apr
29
Tue
all-day IAPP Europe Data Protection Intensive 2014
IAPP Europe Data Protection Inte…
Apr 29 – May 1 all-day
The IAPP Europe Data Protection Intensive features timely programming centred on the top issues impacting the European data protection community, with a focus on addressing [...]
Apr
30
Wed
5:30 pm InSecurity: Race, Surveillance and Privacy in the Digital Age @ New America Foundation
InSecurity: Race, Surveillance a… @ New America Foundation
Apr 30 @ 5:30 pm – 7:30 pm
Now more than ever, digital tools sit at a precarious tipping point, and many question whether they will be used to address pre-existing disparities, [...]
May
2
Fri
all-day Foreign Intelligence Surveillance in an Era of “Big Data” @ Jacob Burns Moot Court Room, George Washington Law School
Foreign Intelligence Surveillanc… @ Jacob Burns Moot Court Room, George Washington Law School
May 2 all-day
Discussions: Panel 1: Why Do We Conduct Foreign Intelligence Surveillance? What Are the Requirements? Panel 2: Making the Trade-Offs Between Surveillance and Civil Liberties Panel [...]
May
7
Wed
all-day IAPP Canada Privacy Symposium 2014
IAPP Canada Privacy Symposium 2014
May 7 – May 9 all-day
The IAPP Canada Privacy Symposium is the leading conference for education, debate and discussion of issues that matter most to Canadian privacy and data protection [...]
Jun
5
Thu
all-day Privacy Law Scholars Conference (7th Annual) @ The George Washington School of Law
Privacy Law Scholars Conference … @ The George Washington School of Law
Jun 5 – Jun 6 all-day
  UC Berkeley School of Law and The George Washington University Law School will be holding the seventh annual Privacy Law Scholars Conference (PLSC) on [...]
Jun
8
Sun
all-day Computers, Freedom, and Privacy 2014 Conference @ Airlie Center
Computers, Freedom, and Privacy … @ Airlie Center
Jun 8 – Jun 10 all-day
Mark your calendars! The 2014 Computers, Freedom, and Privacy Conference will be held June 8-10 at the Airlie Center in Warrenton, Virginia. The Airlie Center [...]
Jan
28
Wed
all-day Data Privacy Day
Data Privacy Day
Jan 28 all-day
“Data Privacy Day began in the United States and Canada in January 2008, as an extension of the Data Protection Day celebration in Europe. The [...]

View Calendar